Reports of the Commissioner's Findings back to main

 
The following Reports of the Commissioner’s Findings are issued pursuant to subsection 73(1) of the Right to Information and Protection of Privacy Act, S.N.B. c.R-10.6.

2015-2858-AP-1546 (Department of Tourism, Heritage and Culture)
Case about access to a government department’s archaeologist inspection report
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed in part
Click here

Report No. 2015-2726-AP-1506 (NB Liquor)
Case about what not to do when receiving and processing a request for access to information submitted under the Right to Information and Protection of Privacy Act
RECOMMENDATIONS
 ISSUED: Followed
Click here for Report
Click here for follow-up regarding recommendations

Report No. 2015-2483-AP-1364 (Horizon Health Network)
Case about disclosure of contracts regarding third party suppliers of orthopedic devices held by a public body through an external group purchasing organization
RECOMMENDATION ISSUED: Not followed
Click here

Report No. 2015-2348-AP-1282 (FacilicorpNB)
Case about disclosure of evaluation documents relating to hospital laundry services
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed in part
Click here

Report No. 2015-2223-AP-2201 (Town of Saint Andrews)
Case about access to the Kingsbrae Gardens Master Plan with the Town of Saint Andrews
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Not followed
Click here

Report No. 2014-2189-AP-1182 (Atlantic Lotto Corporation)
Case about a third party complaint for not agreeing to the intended release of requested information about itself in response to an access request by Atlantic Lotto Corporation
RECOMMENDATION ISSUED: Followed
Click here

Report No. 2014-2090-AP-1130 (Department of Social Development)
Case about access to personnel files, competition files, and reference check information
NO RECOMMENDATION ISSUED
Click here

Report No. 2014-1902-AP-1038 (Department of Natural Resources)
Case about access to the Province's agreement with a forest company licensee
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Follow-up ongoing
Click here

Report No. 2014-1810-AP-983 (Saint Thomas University)
Case about disclosure of salary, bonus, pension, and severance information for University employees
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed in part
Click here

Report No. 2014-1809-AP-982 (Mount Allison University)
Case about disclosure of salary, bonus, pension, and severance information for University employees
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Not followed
Click here

Report No. 2014-1739-AP-948 (Department of Social Development)
Case about access to one’s own personal information at a special care home held by the Department of Health, through a family member with an Enduring Power of Attorney
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed in part
Click here

Report No. 2014-1738-AP-947 (Department of Social Development)
Case about access to special care home investigation information
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed in part
Click here

Report No. 2014-1707-AP-925 (Village of Kedgwick)
Case about whether a public body is entitled to request clarification from the Applicant of an access request
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Follow-up ongoing
Click here

Report No. 2013-1700-AP-921 et al. (Department of Social Development)
Case about failure to respond to access requests
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed
Click here

Report No. 2013-1670-AP-902 (Department of Social Development)
Case about failure to respond to a correction of records request
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed
Click here

Report No. 2013-1669-AP-901 (Town of Quispamsis)
Case about a citizen's access to an insurance adjuster's report from his municipality
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Not followed
Click here

Report No. 2013-1656-AP-893 (Université de Moncton)
Case about access to third party services provided to Université de Moncton
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed
Click here

Report No. 2013-1608-AP-859 et al. (Regional Service Commission 2)
Case about the statutory obligations of a public body when responding to an access request
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed
Click here

Report No. 2013-1598-AP-852 (Department of Social Development)
Case about failure to respond to a request within the time prescribed by the Act
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed
Click here

Report No. 2013-1555-AP-830 (Department of Transportation and Infrastructure)
Case about adequacy of search for relevant records and meaningfulness of response
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed
Click here

Report No. 2013-1516-AP-803 (Horizon Health Network)
Case about failure to disclose public procurement information
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed in part
Click here

Report No. 2013-1500-AP-793 (Department of Public Safety)
Case about access to records generated by Public Interest Disclosure Act
NO RECOMMENDATION ISSUED
Click here

Report No. 2013-1493-AP-789 (Mount Allison University)
Case about access to the University Presidents' employment contracts
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Not followed
Click here

Report No. 2013-1491-AP-787 (Saint Thomas University)
Case about access to pension amounts found in the University Presidents’ employment contracts
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Not followed
(Translation pending. Please contact us for further information)

Report No. 2013-1490-AP-786 (University of New Brunswick)
Case about access to the University President's employment contract
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Not followed
(Translation pending. Please contact us for further information)

Report No. 2013-1437-AP-748 et al. (New Brunswick Community College)
Case about access to personal information and the job competition process
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed in part
Click here

Report No. 2013-1389-AP-720 (Anglophone School District North)
Case about failure to respond to a request
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed
Click here

Report No. 2013-1388-AP-719 (Anglophone School District East)
Case about failure to respond to a request
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed
Click here

Report No. 2013-1374-AP-707 et al. (Department of Finance, Office of Human Resources, Department of Justice and Attorney General, Executive Council Office, and Office of the Premier)
Case about access to information regarding the Shared Risk Pension Plan
NO RECOMMENDATION ISSUED
Click here

Report No. 2013-1368-AP-702 (Department of Education and Early Childhood Development)
Case about a privacy breach in the education system (sharing of student information)
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Follow-up ongoing
Click here

Report No. 2013-1345-AP-691 (Department of Finance)
Case about a request to access information regarding shale gas submitted to the Department of Finance
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Not followed
Click here

Report No. 2013-1343-AP-689 (New Brunswick Liquor Corporation)
Case about unsuccessful bidder's access to the tendering information
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed
Click here

Report No. 2013-1315-AP-675 (Department of Justice and Attorney General)
Case about access to personal information
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Not followed
Click here

Report No. 2013-1281-AP-619 (Department of Environment and Local Government)
Case about failure to respond to a request
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed
Click here

Report No. 2013-1183-AP-607 (Town of St. George)
Case about unsuccessful bidder's access to the tendering information
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed
Click here

Report No. 2012-1100-AP-563 (Department of Tourism, Heritage and Culture)
Case about access to the visitors' log at Larry's Gulch
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed
Click here

Report No. 2013-1065-AP-547 (FacilicorpNB)
Case about an unsuccessful bidder wanting access to the results of the proposals submitted to Facilicorp NB for a security contract
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed in part
Click here

Report No. 2012-1050-AP-539 (Université de Moncton)
Case about access to recteur and former recteur salaries and expenses
NO RECOMMENDATION ISSUED
Click here

Report No. 2012-1048-AP-537 et al. (Mount Allison University)
Case about access to president and senior staff salaries and expenses
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed in part
Click here

Report No. 2012-1038-AP-531 (Horizon Health Network)
Case about access to records that are part of ongoing litigation
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed
Click here

Report No. 2012-1006-AP-510 (Office of the Attorney General)
Case about access to information regarding natural gas distribution and energy policy
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Not followed, appeal concluded
Click here

Report No. 2012-1005-AP-509 (Department of Transportation)
Case about access to information regarding natural gas distribution and energy policy
NO RECOMMENDATION ISSUED
Click here

Report No. 2012-1004-AP-508 (Department of Environment and Local Government)
Case about access to information regarding natural gas distribution and energy policy
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed
Click here

Report No. 2012-1002-AP-506 (Office of the Premier)
Case about access to information regarding natural gas distribution and energy policy
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed in part
Click here

Report No. 2012-992-AP-501 (Department of Environment and Local Government)
Case about failure to provide a response and the decision to refuse access to information based on another legislation
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed
Click here

Commissioner's Ruling No. 2012-905-AP-462; 2012-903-AP-460; 2012-904-AP-461; 2012-901-AP-458
Late complaints
Click here

Report No. 2012-902-AP-459 (Department of Energy)
Case about access to information regarding natural gas distribution and energy policy
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Not followed
Click here

Report No. 2012-900-AP-457 (Executive Council Office)
Case about access to information regarding natural gas distribution and energy policy
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Not followed
Click here

Report No. 2012-855-AP-430 (Department of Justice and Attorney General)
Case about the format of the response and refusing access in full to the requested information
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Not followed
Click here

Report No. 2012-752-AP-381 (Department of Natural Resources)
Case about access  to a personnel investigation report
NO RECOMMENDATION ISSUED
Click Here

Report No. 2012-728-AP-370 (Horizon Health Network)
Case about access to personal information and whether or not it constitutes the Applicant's personal health information
NO RECOMMENDATION ISSUED
Click here

Report No. 2012-674-AP-341 (Department of Public Safety)
Case about access to inmate nutritional information in New Brunswick correctional facilities
NO RECOMMENDATION ISSUED
Click here

Report No. 2012-671-AP-339 (Department of Transportation)
Case about access to information regarding a road condition
NO RECOMMENDATION ISSUED
Click here

Report No. 2012-645-AP-325 (Department of Social Development)
Case about access to information of an ongoing court action
NO RECOMMENDATION ISSUED
Click here

Report No. 2011-636-AP-320 (Department of Transportation)
Case about failure to respond to a request
NO RECOMMENDATION ISSUED
Click here

Report No. 2011-580-AP-296 (Department of Wellness, Culture and Sport)
Case about access to information regarding a heritage designation process
NO RECOMMENDATION ISSUED
Click here

Report No. 2011-576-AP-293 (Department of Wellness, Culture and Sport)
Case about time extension for responding to a request
NO RECOMMENDATION ISSUED
Click here

Report No. 2011-530-AP-273 (Ambulance New Brunswick)
Case about access to information surrounding a personnel investigation
NO RECOMMENDATION ISSUED
Click here

Report No. 2011-430-AP-228 (Executive Council Office)
Case about failure to respond to a request
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed
Click here

Report No. 2011-235-AP-124 (Service New Brunswick)
Case about access to data used for property assessment
NO RECOMMENDATION ISSUED
Click here

Report No. 2011-212-AP-110 (Office of the Attorney General)
Case about access to invoices for legal fees
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Not followed
Click here

Report No. 2011-174-AP-085 (Horizon Health Network)
Case about access to information about deaths in hospitals' psychiatric units
NO RECOMMENDATION ISSUED
Click here

Report No. 2011-145-AP-070 (Department of Agriculture, Aquaculture and Fisheries)
Case about access to sea lice counts
NO RECOMMENDATION ISSUED
Click here

Report No. 2010-120-AP-055 (New Brunswick Liquor Corporation)
Case about access to documents on the executive compensation study
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed in part
Click here

Report No. 2010-108-AP-050 (New Brunswick Liquor Corporation)
Case about access to documents on the executive compensation study
RECOMMENDATIONS ISSUED: Followed in part
Click here

Report No. 2010-105-AP-048 (Department of Agriculture, Aquaculture and Fisheries)
Case about access to sea lice counts
NO RECOMMENDATION ISSUED
Click here

Report No. 2010-102-AP-047 (Horizon Health Network)
Case about access to personal information
NO RECOMMENDATION ISSUED
Click here